Paynters Mill Condos for Sale

Paynters Mill Condos for Sale

Welcome to Paynters Mill, a charming subdivision nestled in the heart of Milton, Delaware. This delightful community offers an idyllic blend of small-town charm and modern convenience, making it the perfect place to call home. Surrounded by the picturesque landscapes of Sussex County, Paynters Mill is renowned for its friendly atmosphere, beautifully landscaped streets, and a strong sense of community.

At Paynters Mill, you will find a variety of condos for sale that cater to diverse lifestyles and preferences. These thoughtfully designed residences range from cozy one-bedroom units to spacious multi-bedroom condos, ensuring that there’s something for everyone. Each condo features modern amenities, open floor plans, and high-quality finishes, providing a perfect backdrop for your personal style. Residents enjoy access to community amenities, including a sparkling swimming pool, walking trails, and recreational areas, fostering a vibrant community spirit.

Living in Paynters Mill means you’re just a stone’s throw away from the charming downtown area of Milton, where you can explore local shops, delightful eateries, and cultural attractions. Additionally, the stunning Delaware beaches are only a short drive away, offering endless opportunities for relaxation and recreation.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, looking to downsize, or seeking a vacation retreat, Paynters Mill condos present an exceptional opportunity. Embrace the lifestyle you’ve always dreamed of in this beautiful subdivision, where comfort, community, and convenience come together. Discover your perfect condo today in Paynters Mill!

Newest Paynters Mill Condos for Sale

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Below market price Estate Sale: A great condo in Paynter's Mill. Approx. 3 miles North of "Five Points" in Lewes. New flooring and newly painted interior.

16626 John Rowland Trl Unit #606, Milton

Listing courtesy of CALLAWAY FARNELL AND MOORE. Contact: 3026294514

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Turnkey Coastal Haven in Paynters Mill! This Home is all its Fully Furnished with an Updated Kitchen in a Prime Lewes/Milton Coastal Location. Welcome to easy, resort-style living in the highly sought-after community of Paynters Mill! This beautifully updated, fully furnished turnkey condo offers the ideal balance of modern comfort, convenience, and endless coastal charm—just pack your bags and start enjoying the beach lifestyle from day one. The Interior Highlights are : Gourmet Updated Kitchen: Cook and entertain in style with newly updated cabinetry, stylish modern hardware, and gorgeous quartz countertops. Spacious Open Floor Plan: The seamless flow between the kitchen, dining, and main living areas creates an inviting atmosphere filled with natural light—perfect for relaxing or hosting guests. Primary Retreat: Enjoy a generous main bedroom suite complete with a private ensuite bathroom and a roomy walk-in closet. Peace of Mind: Features an HVAC system replaced just one year ago and an oversized 1-car garage providing plenty of room for parking, extra storage, or your beach gear. Paynters Mill offers a unique, vibrant neighborhood feel where everything you need is just steps away. Take advantage of the Resort stle Amenities of community clubhouse, fitness center, outdoor pool, hot tub, library, playground, basketball court, and tennis courts. Community offers walkable lifestyle where you can stroll right from your front door to local neighborhood favorites including a hair salon, cozy breakfast nook, delicious pizza shop, and local dining. The location is a Cyclist’s Paradise with direct access to the local bike trail system (Georgetown-Lewes Trail) making it effortless to hop on your bike and ride straight into Downtown Lewes with seamless connections onward to Rehoboth Beach. Location, Location, Location! Situated just minutes from Historic Downtown Lewes & Savannah Beach, the Tanger Outlets, premier shopping, and dining along Route 1, as well as the Cape Henlopen State Park and coastal Delaware's finest beaches. Whether you're looking for a low-maintenance primary residence, a coastal getaway, or a turnkey investment, this Paynters Mill gem is ready for you!

16359 Abraham Potter Run Unit #205, Milton

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Associates. Contact: 3026450800

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Condo in Paynters Mill Welcome to this spacious second‑floor condo located in the highly sought‑after Paynters Mill community. Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, this home offers an ideal blend of comfort, convenience, and low‑maintenance living. The bright and open floor plan includes a large living area with plenty of natural light, a well‑appointed kitchen, and a private balcony perfect for relaxing outdoors. The home also comes with a two‑car garage—a rare and valuable feature in the community. Enjoy peace of mind with major upgrades already done for you, including a new HVAC system installed less than one year ago. Nestled in a beautifully maintained neighborhood with walking paths, community pool, tennis courts, and easy access to shopping, dining, and area beaches, this condo is perfect as a primary residence, beach retreat, or investment opportunity. Move‑in ready and full of charm—don’t miss this one! Professional photos coming next week.

30847 E Annie Lank Ave Unit #1203, Milton

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact: 4438562211

Start Your Search

Joe Sterner

Greetings! I’m Joe Sterner and the Rehoboth Beach area has been home to me since 2003, though my connection to DelMarVa goes back to childhood summers in Ocean City, MD. Originally from Central PA, my partner and I first made coastal Delaware our second home while we owned and operated a national internet marketing company. After selling that successful business in 2013, we moved permanently to Rehoboth Beach, where we purchased The Homestead Bed & Breakfast. As a local bed and breakfast owner, I get to help guests discover coastal Delaware every day. What makes the Delaware beaches truly unique is the lifestyle—and helping people navigate the different communities and towns here is something I genuinely enjoy. My process is simple: I listen carefully to understand your goals, lifestyle, and what you value, and then work with my exceptional team to make your move as seamless as possible. From industry-leading marketing to a vast network of trusted partners, I take care of everything to ensure your move is a success. In addition to my work as an innkeeper and a realtor, I also volunteer on the Clear Space Theatre board as vice-chair. In this role, I’ve had the pleasure of collaborating with people from across our state to help support the arts right here in Rehoboth Beach. To me, the arts are what keep our community vibrant—so if you like theatre or are just curious about what’s happening in town, please don’t be afraid to ask! Additionally, having personally bought and sold millions of dollars in commercial property (both real estate and IP), I regularly work with entrepreneurs and savvy investors to navigate the buying and selling process. When I’m not selling real estate or making breakfast for our B&B guests, you’ll find me hosting dinner parties, surf fishing with friends, tending to the vegetable garden, rooting for my favorite football team in the fall, or simply enjoying a dirty martini in our courtyard. My pledge to you as your agent is the same as if you were a guest in my home or a new neighbor I’m welcoming to the community. You will always receive honesty, hospitality, and straightforward guidance while I work to make your real estate experience as smooth and enjoyable as possible. Cheers!

Learn More

David Brinton

Hello there! My name is David Brinton, and I’ve proudly called Coastal Delaware home since 2003. After years of spending summers here, my husband and I decided to purchase a second home—and before long, we made the move to live in Rehoboth Beach full-time. We quickly fell in love with the coastal lifestyle and welcoming community. From forming lasting friendships to enjoying endless entertainment and exceptional dining, living in Coastal Delaware has truly been a dream come true. Today, I’m grateful to share that same lifestyle with my real estate clients. Helping others create their own life at the beach—while discovering all that these incredible communities have to offer—is incredibly rewarding. There’s nothing better than hearing how happy new residents are after making the move. With a degree in Hospitality Management and a minor in Travel and Tourism, I bring a client-first approach to real estate. I take the time to understand your goals and preferences so I can guide you toward homes and communities that align with your vision. Paired with the expert resources of the Coastal Homestead Group, our partnership delivers exceptional service, unmatched resources, and proven results. In my spare time, I enjoy watching movies, catching a football game, relaxing by the pool at our B&B, fishing, spending time at the beach, and being with friends and family.

Learn More