Bay Colony Homes for Sale

Bay Colony Homes for Sale

**Welcome to Bay Colony: Your Coastal Haven in Dagsboro, DE**

Nestled in the picturesque town of Dagsboro, Delaware, Bay Colony is a charming subdivision that embodies the essence of coastal living. This serene community is perfectly situated just a short drive from the pristine beaches of the Delaware coastline, making it a sought-after destination for those looking to embrace a relaxed, beach-inspired lifestyle.

Bay Colony offers a delightful array of homes for sale, catering to diverse preferences and lifestyles. From spacious single-family residences to cozy townhomes, each property reflects the community’s commitment to quality and comfort. Many homes feature modern amenities, open floor plans, and beautiful outdoor spaces, ideal for entertaining family and friends or simply enjoying the tranquility of your surroundings.

The allure of Bay Colony extends beyond its beautiful homes. Residents enjoy access to a variety of community amenities, including walking trails, recreational facilities, and a welcoming atmosphere that fosters neighborly connections. Whether you’re taking a leisurely stroll along the scenic paths or gathering with friends for a summer barbecue, the sense of community is palpable.

In addition to its stunning homes, Bay Colony is conveniently located near local attractions, shopping, and dining options. Explore nearby natural parks, indulge in fresh seafood at local eateries, or spend a day soaking up the sun on the sandy shores of the Atlantic.

If you’re searching for your dream home in a tranquil setting with a vibrant community spirit, look no further than Bay Colony in Dagsboro, DE. Discover the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and coastal charm—your new home awaits!

Newest Bay Colony Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Well-maintained Colonial-style single-family home in the highly sought after marina community of Bay Colony. This spacious residence offers 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and 3,400 sq ft—ideal for comfortable everyday living and hosting guests. Enjoy the convenience of being close to the beach, nearby golf courses, and a variety of area dining options. Community amenities include tennis courts, pool, and marina access, offering plenty of ways to relax or stay active. A great opportunity to own a thoughtfully cared-for home in a sought-after coastal setting.

29929 Sawmill Dr, Dagsboro

Listing courtesy of LAYTON ASSOCIATES REAL ESTATE. Contact: (302) 537-5599

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

This house is one you really don't want to miss. New in 2017, owners have done considerable upgrades each year to have that perfect house. Upgrades galore with fencing, hard scape front & back, beautiful landscaping w lighting, outside shed has had up graded shelfing. new gas line to grill. And that's just the outside! Rollout shelves in pantry, recently installed butlers bar, master bedroom closets w fit outs, brand new cooktop. Check out the beautiful wallpaper in the dining room. Steps to the pool, clubhouse, bay and marina. Golf carts are allowed. Cripple Creek golf club is directly across from the entrance to Bay Colony. Easy to preview And please check out the video.

29494 Colony Dr, Dagsboro

Listing courtesy of Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.. Contact: (302) 539-9040

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to 29902 Sawmill Drive in Bay Colony, a sought-after waterfront marina community along the Indian River Bay offering exceptional coastal amenities and a relaxed Delaware beach lifestyle. Residents enjoy a private marina with boat slips available for lease or purchase, a private bay beach, pool, clubhouse, tennis, and pickleball courts—plus Cripple Creek Golf & Country Club just across the street! Thoughtfully designed for first-floor living and effortless entertaining, this spacious, beautifully updated home features soaring two-story ceilings, abundant natural light, and an open coastal-inspired layout. The dramatic great room is filled with sunlight from a wall of picture windows and clerestory windows, while the gourmet kitchen offers granite counters, generous cabinetry, deep pantry storage, stainless steel appliances, and a large breakfast bar. The main level also includes a formal dining room, sunlit breakfast room, private office, renovated powder room, mudroom, laundry room, and a luxurious first-floor primary suite with a beautifully updated bath and multiple walk-in closets with built-ins. Upstairs offers a second primary suite with ensuite bath, three additional bedrooms, and a massive flex/recreation room ready for a game room, theater, storage, or additional gathering space. An oversized 22x38 attached garage with workshop area provides excellent space for hobbies, storage, and beach gear. Ideally located near Holts Landing State Park, great restaurants, shopping, and with easy access to major cities, this Bay Colony home offers space, comfort, amenities, and the best of coastal living.

29902 Sawmill Dr, Dagsboro

Listing courtesy of Northrop Realty. Contact: (302) 539-2900

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 34325 Indian River Drive — a show-stopping 6-bedroom, 3-bathroom residence nestled on a prominent corner lot in the coveted, water-oriented community of Bay Colony. Boasting over 4,200 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this impeccably maintained home sets a new standard for luxury and function at the beach. Home will be sold mostly furnished, so all you need to pack is your flip flops to start enjoying all this home has to offer. There is also a slip in the neighborhood marina which can also be purchased at an additional amount. From the moment you arrive, the attention to detail is undeniable. Step onto the spacious front porch, or head up to the second-story balcony, which is finished with authentic boards from the Bethany Beach boardwalk—for a true taste of local charm. Inside, the home is a masterclass in craftsmanship. Expansive, top of the line Andersen windows showcase the view. The dream kitchen is adorned with high-end finishes, perfect for the culinary enthusiast, while multiple living and gathering spaces, including a game room off the main living area and airy loft, provide room for even the extended family to relax or entertain. The main-level primary suite is a serene retreat featuring a spa-like en suite bath and an expansive custom closet. In addition, you'll find even more generously sized bedrooms and a loft offering flexible space for guests or hobbies. An oversized two-car garage with extra-tall doors caters to auto lovers, while practical features like a full-home generator hookup, outdoor shower, and an irrigation system with built-in winterizing capabilities mean every convenience has been considered—no plumber needed. Additional highlights include space prepped for future elevator installation, partial water views, and direct access to Bay Colony’s private beach on the Indian River Bay—just steps from your door. Whether you're seeking a peaceful primary residence or a luxurious coastal getaway, this home checks every box and then some.

34325 Indian River Dr, Dagsboro

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty. Contact: 3023600300

Start Your Search

Joe Sterner

Greetings! I’m Joe Sterner and the Rehoboth Beach area has been home to me since 2003, though my connection to DelMarVa goes back to childhood summers in Ocean City, MD. Originally from Central PA, my partner and I first made coastal Delaware our second home while we owned and operated a national internet marketing company. After selling that successful business in 2013, we moved permanently to Rehoboth Beach, where we purchased The Homestead Bed & Breakfast. As a local bed and breakfast owner, I get to help guests discover coastal Delaware every day. What makes the Delaware beaches truly unique is the lifestyle—and helping people navigate the different communities and towns here is something I genuinely enjoy. My process is simple: I listen carefully to understand your goals, lifestyle, and what you value, and then work with my exceptional team to make your move as seamless as possible. From industry-leading marketing to a vast network of trusted partners, I take care of everything to ensure your move is a success. In addition to my work as an innkeeper and a realtor, I also volunteer on the Clear Space Theatre board as vice-chair. In this role, I’ve had the pleasure of collaborating with people from across our state to help support the arts right here in Rehoboth Beach. To me, the arts are what keep our community vibrant—so if you like theatre or are just curious about what’s happening in town, please don’t be afraid to ask! Additionally, having personally bought and sold millions of dollars in commercial property (both real estate and IP), I regularly work with entrepreneurs and savvy investors to navigate the buying and selling process. When I’m not selling real estate or making breakfast for our B&B guests, you’ll find me hosting dinner parties, surf fishing with friends, tending to the vegetable garden, rooting for my favorite football team in the fall, or simply enjoying a dirty martini in our courtyard. My pledge to you as your agent is the same as if you were a guest in my home or a new neighbor I’m welcoming to the community. You will always receive honesty, hospitality, and straightforward guidance while I work to make your real estate experience as smooth and enjoyable as possible. Cheers!

Learn More

David Brinton

Hello there! My name is David Brinton, and I’ve proudly called Coastal Delaware home since 2003. After years of spending summers here, my husband and I decided to purchase a second home—and before long, we made the move to live in Rehoboth Beach full-time. We quickly fell in love with the coastal lifestyle and welcoming community. From forming lasting friendships to enjoying endless entertainment and exceptional dining, living in Coastal Delaware has truly been a dream come true. Today, I’m grateful to share that same lifestyle with my real estate clients. Helping others create their own life at the beach—while discovering all that these incredible communities have to offer—is incredibly rewarding. There’s nothing better than hearing how happy new residents are after making the move. With a degree in Hospitality Management and a minor in Travel and Tourism, I bring a client-first approach to real estate. I take the time to understand your goals and preferences so I can guide you toward homes and communities that align with your vision. Paired with the expert resources of the Coastal Homestead Group, our partnership delivers exceptional service, unmatched resources, and proven results. In my spare time, I enjoy watching movies, catching a football game, relaxing by the pool at our B&B, fishing, spending time at the beach, and being with friends and family.

Learn More